CultureWatch

Bill Muehlenberg's commentary on issues of the day...

A Church of One

Mar 25, 2015

There will always be disagreement amongst Christians. Indeed, there is nothing wrong with differences of opinions, at least on non-primary biblical doctrines. But one aspect of Christian maturity is learning when and where to pick your fights. Learning what battles are important, and which are not, is part of growing in wisdom.

And learning how to let certain issues go through to the keeper – as the saying goes – is also invaluable. The truth is, one need not engage in every controversy, take sides in every battle, and respond to every questionable thing you encounter.

Sometimes unity is the preferred option. Sometimes standing for truth, even at the risk of breaking Christian unity is preferred. And having the wisdom to know which is the right path is obviously very important. Those involved in public ministry know full well that there can be a million battles a day, and caution and discernment are always needed.

unityI certainly know all about this. Not a day goes by when I am not attacked by various non-Christians. That is to be expected. But also not a day goes by when some Christian wants to pick a fight with me, or has gotten bent out of shape about something I said, or has taken offence, and so on.

I can fully understand why so many Christians never ever open their mouths and discuss anything. It is a lot more quiet and peaceful that way. You avoid a lot of wars! Thus we regrettably have most Christians remaining silent, and not standing for anything, just for fear of all the abuse that might come.

They prefer to avoid all controversy, all disputes, all debates, and all hot potato issues, in order not to rock the boat or get anyone upset. That is one way to go, but not the biblical way. We must all stand for biblical truth, even if it is costly.

But yes, I know how difficult that can be. To stand for anything will risk attacks, division, animosity, and stirring the pot. To have firm convictions about anything will always make waves, ruffle feathers, and create enemies. It can’t be helped.

Indeed, I am surprised that I still have any friends left! Really. At times it is not easy being a Christian. There are so many different camps and different groups and different emphases and different shibboleths being fought for. Some are important – some less so.

In the interests of self-disclosure, let me describe a bit of my own “brand”. This is where I am at. And to have any one of these emphases or convictions will mean someone will get upset. For example,

-I am more or less Reformed, which angers some non-Reformed friends;
-I am open to some Arminian thinking, which angers my anti-Arminian friends;
-I am open to the charismata, which angers my anti-charismatic friends;
-I am not into hyper charismania, which angers some of my charismatic and Pentecostal friends.
-I am friends with some Catholics, even though a staunch Protestant, which angers some of my anti-Catholic friends;
-I am staunchly Protestant, which angers some of my anti-Protestant friends;
-I am staunchly evangelical, which can get some of my non-evangelical friends angry;
-I have a high view of Scripture, which gets some of my friends with a lower view of Scripture angry.
-I am open to some of the revivalists like Finney, which angers my anti-Finney friends;
-I am basically conservative politically and theologically, which angers those who are not;
-I think the mind is very important, which upsets my anti-intellectual friends;
-I think a deep spirituality and holiness is important, which upsets some of my more formal and traditionalist friends;
-I think doctrine and good theology is very important, which upsets some of my experience-only friends;
-I think experience matters, which upsets some of my theology-only friends;
-I am open to gleaning truth from others, even if I don’t agree with all their teaching, which angers the heresy hunters;
-I am open to different eschatological views, which angers many of my friends with certain eschatological views;
-I am in favour of wealth creation, which angers my prosperity gospel friends;
-I am critical of the prosperity gospel, which can wrongly get some of my free-market friends angry;
-I am open to being a cobelligerent with others, which angers many of my more fightin’ fundie friends.

I could keep this list going all day. But hopefully you get my rift. No matter what I believe or favour, that will upset some people. Any strong conviction or theological leaning I may hold to will be certain to upset some folks. It just can’t be helped.

So we have to be prepared to be disliked, hated and opposed by many, simply for having any strong convictions, and for holding to any particular position. That goes with the territory. Learning how to show grace and forbearance to others in the midst of all this is crucial.

I have to tell folks all the time, this is who I am and this is what I believe. If you can accept that, fine, and if not, well perhaps go your own way. And I also have to tell them that just because I support some position or like some theological camp does not mean I necessarily buy into all that they believe.

Just because I quote from some theologian or Christian leader for example does not mean I necessarily agree with everything they might say. I may well disagree with various things they say or believe. Hey, I sometimes even disagree with myself! So unless we want to be a church with just one member, we have to learn to get along where possible, and be a bit more open to others.

So we all must learn how to be a bit more patient, gracious and forbearing with others when disagreements come up. Not everything is worth fighting about, and there are secondary doctrines on which we can agree to disagree. We need to all pray for discernment and wisdom as to which issues to fight to the death over, and which ones to lighten up on.

But to be a Christian means to stand up for truth – especially in the public arena. We must let our light shine in public. Thus controversy will be inevitable. Disagreements will arise. Conflict will happen. We need to pray for God’s favour, guidance, love, grace and truth as we enter into all these battles.

To wrap this up, let me mention the really ironic thing about all this: I actually hate conflict. I prefer to avoid it like the plague. I don’t like all the fights, all the controversies, all the wars, all the skirmishes. Yet this is what I have been called to do.

It is indeed ironic that God has called me into a ministry which results in daily conflict. So I desperately covet your prayers that I might show God’s love and grace, as well as have his wisdom, truth and boldness as I deal with my legion of daily critics, attackers, haters and enemies – many of whom are Christians! I think we all need those sorts of prayers.

As I have said elsewhere, people often discover me and befriend me and initially think I am just terrific. I have come to realise that I must offer them a gentle word of warning: hang around long enough and you will likely find something you won’t like about me. Hang around a bit longer and you will probably become convinced that I am a wretched heretic who needs to be burned at the stake. Happens quite often!

In closing, let me share this story which I have used elsewhere:

Walking across a bridge, I saw a man on the edge, about to jump. I ran over and said: “Stop. Don’t do it.”
“Why not?” he asked.
“Well, there’s so much to live for!”
“Like what?”
“Are you religious?”
He said: “Yes.”
I said: “Me too. Are you Christian or Buddhist?”
“Christian.”
“Me, too. Are you Catholic or Protestant?”
“Protestant.”
“Me, too. Are you Episcopalian or Baptist?”
“Baptist.”
“Me, too. Are you Baptist Church of God or Church of the Lord?”
“Baptist Church of God.”
“Me, too. Are you original Baptist Church of God, or Reformed Baptist Church of God?”
“Reformed Baptist Church of God.”
“Me, too! Are you Reformed Baptist Church of God, Reformation of 1879, or Reformed Baptist
Church of God, Reformation of 1915?”
He said: “Reformation of 1915.”
I said: “Die, heretic scum,” and pushed him off.

[1422 words]

13 Responses to A Church of One

  • You are stuck with me Bill, and I have been around long enough to hear all you have to say and I can only say how much I respect you.

    I wish there were more men and women of God of your calibre. I think denomination is irrelevant, truth will always be the truth, even if very few believe it.

  • I said: “Die, heretic scum,” and pushed him off.

    That’s a good one isn’t it.

    “This is where I am at” and if you ever change where you’re at you’ll anger ….

  • My 5 year old loves to remind me that “there was a man named Noah who was the only man to believe in God and do what God wanted!”

    Abraham was alone. Daniel prayed alone.Elijah and Jeremiah were alone. Jesus died alone. Not that it makes it easy as God recognised that “It is not good that the man should be alone;”

    (2 Timothy 4:16 – 18)At my first answer no man stood with me, but all men forsook me: I pray God that it may not be laid to their charge.

    17 Notwithstanding the Lord stood with me, and strengthened me; that by me the preaching might be fully known, and that all the Gentiles might hear: and I was delivered out of the mouth of the lion.

    18 And the Lord shall deliver me from every evil work, and will preserve me unto his heavenly kingdom: to whom be glory for ever and ever. Amen.

    This the battle-scarred Paul wrote in describing his appearance before a civil court to answer for his life of believing and teaching contrary to the Roman world.

    The apostle was delivered out of the mouth of the lion, that is, of Nero, or some of his judges. If the Lord stands by us, he will strengthen us in difficulties and dangers, and his presence will more than supply every one’s absence. ( Matthew Henry)

  • Yes – Yes – and Yes, brother Bill.

    Yes you will get some stuff “right”.
    Yes you will get some stuff “wrong”.
    Yes you must stand up for TRUTH – regardless of who agrees with the “right” or the “wrong” – or so perceived.

    Thank you for at least having an opinion of value, and then bothering to share it with us.

    Iron sharpens iron, and should we find things that question our own theology (or not), we should be drawn closer to the fruit tree of life – for the “pickings”…in order to discern where we ourselves stand on that same issue.

    Love your heart. Thank you and be blessed.
    Leila Nord.

  • In all things we are to become more like Jesus. No matter the subject matter, we can be very right and come out of alignment with our Heavenly Father’s heart.

    Bill, I have read hundreds and hundreds of your articles over the years and there have been very few times I could fault where you were coming from. Those rare times I have written to voice my particular concern…. always with the motivation of wanting you to come silently before the Lord for what was on His heart regarding the issue… never to harm you or bring you down.

    Your voice in the wilderness is very much needed and appreciated. The Body needs what God has placed in you – yoour passion to expose and expound… your ability to articulate so clearly…. and I see you mostly as a watchman – come to warn and arrest us in our tracks…. STOP! LOOK! LISTEN!!!……and to plead with us to turn back from our wicked ways! And I feel you must plead on our behalf before the Lord as well, “Lord forgive them… open their eyes… heal and release your flock. Refresh and empower them, Lord, to be all you have called them to be at this time”

    For all this I thank you, Bill. I thank God for you. I pray that you will continue to do all He has called you to do…. that doors will open wider and wider for you to step through. But…. by now you will know that for every action there is a reaction…. and for that we must have lots of personal time with the Lord, and lots of back-up prayer so we can stand in the battle and beyond, as Jesus did. God bless and strengthen you, let his face shine upon you, and give you His peace. Amen

  • *Big Smile*

    God bless you brother Bill!

    Keep on going, keep on working, keep being faithful to our Lord and his word. You encourage more people than you will ever know. Ignore the hate and vitriol.

    Thank you once again.

    Your humble southern brother
    David

  • I’m still waiting to read something that I disagree with…

    You have a hard calling to be sure Bill , but very much needed and appreciated.

    Regards,
    Annette

  • To me you are a Watchman to the Christians, a Prophet to the non believers. God bless and protect you, your family and this site.

  • Bill, I agree with all said here. We need to make sure we are truly hearing the HOLY SPIRIT and not to satan. The only thing not the is that I am a Wesleyan. I am glad to hear anything anyone has to say. I love all.

  • I am about to write that list of all the things on which I disagree with you, Bill. Now where is that tram ticket?

    (Assuming anyone remembers tram tickets)

  • No – wait a minute. But I still think your articles are great.

  • Just as well that “love rejoices in the truth” 1 Cor 13. Together with “speak the truth in love” Eph 4. Shouldn’t that be enough to keep all of God’s sheep together under the loving eye of one shepherd?
    Many blessings
    Ursula Bennett

Leave a Reply